Yahoo China Lawsuit Settled
November 14, 2007 | by Christopher Nickson
Yahoo has agreed to settle a lawsuit brought against it by Human Rights USA regarding information that led to the jailing of two Chinese dissidents.
After its mauling at the hands of a Congressional panel last week, Yahoo has agreed to settle a suit brought against it by the World Organization for Human Rights USA. The aim of the suit had been to show Yahoo’s complicity in the arrests of Chinese dissidents when the company gave user information to Chinese authorities.
As a result of Yahoo passing on that information, journalist Shi Tao was arrested and imprisoned, along with writer Wang Xiaoning. Both are now serving 10-year jail terms for the “subversion of state power” and “sharing state secrets.”
Neither side has issued details of the settlement, although it’s believed to include a deal whereby Yahoo will try to secure the release of the imprisoned men, an understanding as to actions Yahoo will take when approached to identify users in future, and efforts to meet the humanitarian needs of those who have been unlawfully detained as a result of Yahoo's actions.
Last year, Yahoo's executive vice-president and general counsel Michael Callahan explained to a congressional panel that he’d had no knowledge as to why the Chinese authorities had wanted to trace Shi Tao. He claimed that the company had to comply with Chinese laws in order to do business there.
But last week he admitted that other Yahoo employees had been in possession of a document saying the search was to do with the "suspected illegal provision of state secrets,” although he claimed he wasn’t aware of that information until months after his testimony. In response, a Congressional panel called Yahoo’s actions "at best inexcusably negligent" and at worst "deceptive."
Post Your Comment...Comments
Comment on this article
Please keep your comments relevant to this article. Email addresses are not displayed, they are only required to verify you are human.
When you submit your comment, an email will be sent to your email address with a confirmation link. Once you have clicked on that confirmation link your comment will be posted.
HTML is not allowed.
RSS Feed
allen on Nov 25th, 2008 at 8:01 PM:
White Terror Reoccurs in Taiwan - Yahoo! shut down Mango Daily
白色恐—重現台£ - Yahoo!關—'果•報郮落格
Yahoo! Taiwan shut down a popular personal blog - Mango Daily ( http://tw.myblog.yahoo.com/antired-newspaper) on Nov.21, 2008. Mango Daily is a popular and awarded blog that voices for Taiwanese democracy.
Mango Daily's recent article about a protest rally against China envoy's visit to Taiwan infuriated a riot control policeman and that officer asked Yahoo! to shut down Mango Daily. Yahoo! removed a Mango Daily's article and finally shut down that blog on 3:00pm, Nov.21, 2008. Again, Yahoo! played its role as an agent of totalitarian.
Yahoo! was notorious for its cooperation with totalitarian. In 2004, Yahoo! provided users' IP information to Chinese government and that led to Chinese journalist Shi Tao's 10 years of sentence in Chinese prison. (Shi Tao was a journalist, but not Jack Bauer. 24's(Fox TV) Jack Bauer was in Chinese prison only for 20 months)
It seems that Yahoo! did not learn any lesson from Shi Tao's case. Furthermore, Chinese government might get its dirty hands in Taiwanese democracy with the assistance of Yahoo! (Hong Kong) Holdings Ltd. Yahoo! (Hong Kong) Holdings' shamful behavior directly led to the conviction of a good journalist.
From recent Mango Daily's case, Taiwanese people who own blogs and email accounts at Yahoo! should be very careful with Yahoo's human rights record.